Connect with us

Pirates Trade Rumors

MLB Trade Deadline: What Could Pirates Get for David Bednar?



Pittsburgh Pirates David Bednar

If the Pittsburgh Pirates traded David Bednar before the Aug. 2 deadline, it would likely cause a bit of a furor.

A case could be made that Bednar is the Pirates’ most popular player. The crowd at PNC Park rarely gets louder than when Bednar comes in from the bullpen to the song “Renegade.” He was the Pirates’ representative in the All-Star Game earlier this month.

And, of course, Bednar is a Mars High School graduate. That provides plenty of gravitas in a provincial area like Western Pennsylvania.

All indications are the Pirates have no plans to deal the 27-year-old. However, plenty of teams would love to have Bednar for the pennant race and beyond, so perhaps a rival general manager will overwhelm Ben Cherington with an offer.

As we did Tuesday with Bryan Reynolds, we ran Bednar’s name through the trade simulator at and paired him with five teams that have expressed interest. The site attempts to put a value on each player while accounting for his contract status.

Some potential Bednar deals validated by the site’s trade simulator can be found below and it is clear he would not fetch as much as Reynolds. Not saying these trades are going to happen, or I would do them. It’s just what the computer says.

New York Yankees

Pirates get two prospects – shortstop Oswald Peraza and right-hander Will Warren.

The 22-year-old Peraza is playing at Triple-A, and Warren, 23, is pitching at Double-A. Baseball America ranks Peraza as the Yankees’ second-best prospect and No. 77 in all of baseball, while Warren is No. 9 in the organization.

Los Angeles Dodgers

Pirates get right-handed pitching prospect Bobby Miller.

The 23-year-old is pitching at Double-A. BA rates Miller as the Dodgers’ No. 2 prospect and the 25th-best in the game.

It’s hard to imagine the Dodgers doing this deal but that’s what the simulator came up with.

Minnesota Twins

Pirates get outfielder Trevor Larnach and left-handed pitching prospect Christian MacLeod.

Currently on the injured list, the 25-year-old Larnach is hitting .231/.306/.406 with five home runs in 51 games for the Twins this season. MacLeod, 22, is sitting out the season while recovering from Tommy John reconstructive elbow after being the Twins’ fifth-round draft pick last year.

San Diego Padres

Pirates get two prospects – outfielder James Wood and right-hander Jarlin Susana.

Both are teenagers as Wood is 19 and Susana is 18. Wood is playing at the Low-Class A level and Susana in the Arizona Complex League.

Tampa Bay Rays

The Pirates get two players off the major league team in rookie outfielder Josh Lowe and infielder Taylor Walls.

Lowe, 24, is hitting .203/.259/.331 with two home runs in 49 games. Walls, 26, has a .171/.253/.279 slash line and four home runs in 86 games.

The simulator has to be questioned here, too, as the Pirates could seemingly get at least one better player for Bednar.

Welcome to your new home for Pittsburgh Pirates breaking news, analysis and opinion from John Perrotto, Cody Potanko, Danny Demilio and the Pirates Now crew. Subscribe for insider content and an ad-free browsing experience. Like us on Facebook, and follow us on Twitter.
Notify of
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Chris L Spera

Of these i would take the San Diego deal….but the Yankess deal is close too


The Rays would never include Lowe, he is going to be very good, he is just a rookie? Walls and a prospect in the 10 to 15 range? But why would the pirates want a shortstop? Stupid trade idea


I’d deal with the NYY, but word is they won’t deal Perazza so I’d center the trade around #5 LHP Waldichuk (AAA) & #7 RHP Wesneski (AAA). Waldichuk has been dominant & could be a great #2 while Wesneski has also been solid & could be a good #3. Since this centers around guys outside their top 4, I’d try to squeeze in either #11 RHP Medina (AA) or #15 RHP Vasquez (AA). Medina has an electric fastball & could be a great closer if he fails as a starter & Vasquez has a great curveball.

All of these guys are close to MLB ready & would fit perfectly into our window. Bednar has been great, but if we can flip him for 2-3 good SPs then they have to do it. It’s much easier to buy RPs & even good closers in free agency then it is to find good starting pitching.

Jed Weisberger

He would fit well with the Yankees. Not sure they would put Pedaza in the deal. Bucs could use Miguel Andujar’s offense, perhaps. Great piece.

PBN Podcast

PBN in your Inbox

Enter your email address to get all of our posts sent directly to your inbox.

PBN on Facebook

Copyright © 2021 Pittsburgh Baseball Network and Pittsburgh Sports Now. All rights reserved. In no way endorsed by the Pittsburgh Pirates or Major League Baseball.

Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER (PA/IL) or 1-800-9-WITH-IT (IN only) or 1-800-BETS-OFF (IA only) or 1-800-522-4700 (CO Only) or TN REDLINE: 800-889-9789.

Be the first to know...

Sign up and get all of our articles sent straight to your inbox.

Thank you for subscribing.

Something went wrong.