Pirates
Potential Pirates Trade Targets: Two First Base Options From Orioles
This is one in a series of examining potential trade targets for the Pittsburgh Pirates in the 2024-25 offseason.
It’s a statement that is seemingly fits annually at this rate but the Pittsburgh Pirates need an upgrade at first base this offseason.
Offense will be the primary focus for general manager Ben Cherington this winter in hopes of assembling a playoff-caliber team for 2025. That focus starts at first base.
There are a handful of notable free agent options for the Pirates to consider this winter. The top of that list will be too rich for Pittsburgh. Baring a miracle, Pete Alonso and Christian Walker will not be wearing black and gold threads next year.
If the Pirates want to make a meaningful upgrade at the position instead of patchwork with no long-term solution in sight, parting with young assets as part of trades could be the way to go.
Looking at the potential trade market, the Pirates matchup well with the Baltimore Orioles, who could have a couple of guys available.
Ryan Mountcastle played 114 games at first base for the Orioles this season, his fifth year in the big leagues. Throughout his Major League Career, the 27-year-old has been a steady producer with the bat and has seen his defense improve dramatically of late.
Mountcastle hit .271 with a .733 OPS, 30 doubles, two triples, 13 home runs and 63 RBIs. His home run total would have likely been larger had it not been for the over-the-top big left field at Camden Yards. The right-handed hitter has been an above-average offensive performer each year of his career and owns a 112 wRC+.
But Mountcastle isn’t the only potential option for the Pirates from Baltimore. Teammate Ryan O’Hearn is perhaps an even likelier trade candidate.
O’Hearn, 31, began his career with the Kansas City Royals but didn’t breakout until he joined the Orioles prior to the 2023 season. In 254 games with Baltimore over the past two seasons, O’Hearn has slashed .275/.329/.450 with 43 doubles, four triples, 29 home runs and 119 RBIs.
He’s split time between first base, the corner outfield and designated hitter. While he’s not nearly as good a defender as Mountcastle, he’s been a bit better with the bat in his hands.
The two players are in different contract situations but would not break the Pirates’ bank. With that being said, the salary they would need to take on to acquire either player wouldn’t be inconsequential, either.
Mountcastle is arbitation-eligible again this offseason and is projected for a $6.6 million salary, according to MLB Trade Rumors. He won’t hit free agency until after the 2026 season. O’Hearn, meanwhile, has an $8 million club option for 2025 and will be a free agent at season’s end.
On the Orioles end of things, they have no shortage of position players. However, they will need starting pitching help, especially with ace Corbin Burnes set for free agency.
The Pirates, despite their flaws, have starting pitching depth both on the big league roster and in the upper levels of the minor leagues.
The two teams got together for a trade at the deadline with each side dealing prospects from areas of strength. The Pirates received outfielder Billy Cook in exchange for right-hander Patrick Reilly.
Maybe Cherington will call Mike Elias once again to acquire an established big-leaguer to help the Pirates in 2025.
Moundcastle for Holderman